Batman or Superman? Kirk or Picard? Would you prefer to have the power of invisibility or of flight? Describe your best Halloween costume. At age ten, who was your favorite fictional character, and why? Who would it be today? Tell us about a time you were fired from a job. Explain in five hundred words what you believe in. If you were a flower, what kind of flower would you be?
If I waited for an original idea to begin working, I think I’d get as far as actually tearing my eyeballs out of my head before I gave up and joined a monastery. Diving right in, then. Batman. Kirk. (In case you weren’t aware, Krik or Spock? is not a question. You’ve completely missed the point.) To be brutally honest? Invisibility. I know. We can talk about it later.
—
What I remember about Halloween, other than how surprising it was every year that I could and did forget that it bumps right up against my birthday, is being disappointed with myself on the costume front. Maybe there is nothing I actually enjoy about dressing up, and my expectations were all unconsciously based on movie montages set to aggressively fun music, but it seemed like something I should be good at, something I should have fun with. My failure to do so was dismaying, and painful.
When it came to costumes, as in my other earthly pursuits, I aim high. None of the standard ghouls for me. Come to think of it, Halloween never really had much to do with fear or fright in my experience, but it’s not just that plastic moulds of Frankenstein’s monster didn’t pass muster. The standard costumes are familiar to everyone, I’m sure, but just to make fresh in your memory the utter inanity of this peculiar cottage industry, let’s review.
There are doctors and nurses, a strangely mythical rendering of a real world profession which may contribute to our love of soap operas set in hospitals and our expensive inability to resist a sales pitch from someone in a white coat. You can purchase superhero clothing that makes you look even less glamorous than you usually do, which is strange because it seems to go the other way on the superheros. You can be a pirate, which in light of the internet and the Indian Ocean makes less and less sense every day.
Bizzare aside: I did hear on EconTalk that the voluntary arrangements among eighteenth century pirate ships were atypically democratic for the times, possibly influencing subsequent governance, but even if we grant them that, it isn’t really what we like about them, is it. Maybe we make protagonists of mobsters, bank robbers and pirates because in our lives we resent the criminalization of victimless acts and therefore admire the balls it takes to disregard a law. Unfortunate then that the crimes we glorify are ones with victims. Pirates, the real ones who stole rivalrous and excludable things, may have occasionally had more fun than other denizens of the eighteenth century, but they did so on the backs of others and therefore don’t deserve our respect or our Halloween tributes.
So: no good options. I was looking for a costume that looked good, referenced something reasonably cool from popular culture, made immediate sense to onlookers, could be assembled from things we had lying around the house, and took about half an hour to take from conception to completion. No real successes, I’m sorry to report. Lest you think my criteria were unreasonable, and look to blame my failure on an unwillingness to purchase something, plan ahead, or otherwise put at my disposal anything other than my usual wardrobe, I’ll have you know it can be done. I had a friend, the one I always ended up trick or treating with, who pulled it off, year after year, making it look silly to do anything else. He appeared to spend no time or effort. He bought nothing, he never dressed in logo-printed polyester, and let me tell you, he looked good.
This was my general impression, but if pressed for specifics I can’t recall many. The costumes that impressed me included my friend throwing on a fedora and a suit jacket and calling himself a gangster. (So effortless! So cool! Why did this never happen to me? Where did he get a suit jacket?) Another year the article of clothing he found lying around his house was a wide, round hat pointed at the top which his father brought home from Vietnam. I think these are used by poor peasants who farm rice and need to keep the sun off their necks, but here, on him, it signified something much sexier and exotic. Were there ninjas in Vietnam? Probably not. It did not matter. No one was reminded of a farmer. He was, if I may, ninjaesque.
As for the embarrassing results of my attempts to replicate his feat, the only one I remember with any clarity was the year I put on my grandfather’s long black wool coat. It is with great difficulty that I reveal to you, in a spirit of openness and honesty, and not letting the past hang over us and all that, that the only thing I found to accessorize the coat with was, wait for it, balloons. Several balloons, I seem to recall, floating along over my head, just begging the question. I answered, with the heavy resignation of someone who is waiting patiently for this night to be over, that I was a balloon seller. You know. A balloon seller.
I’m not enjoying this, but I want to spell it out for you: I did not look good. My already tenuous self esteem was taking body blows every time someone new looked my way. I had no connection to any cool character, past or present. I also was not identifiable, not easily and not ever, not even after I’d done my best to explain, and my best, by that point, had moved past half-hearted and was actively flirting with words like “sulking,” “gloomy,” and “inaudible.” I didn’t know what I was myself. Couldn’t explain it. I couldn’t figure how I had come to be in such a awful position, scrambling the night of Halloween for something, anything, considering that costumes typically appeared, fully formed and awesome, a week before the holiday, after the discovery of some obvious and effortless linchpin garment, preferably one brought from a far away land, by a father, maybe.
That year as we walked through town I remember running into a classmate, a pretty and intimidating blond, surrounded by her friends and looking the opposite of an embarrassment. Not being far removed from elementary school and its automatic intimacy, we knew each other, and said hello, although this girl wouldn’t have considered herself a friend of mine. I was mortified. I think I tried to avoid even mentioning the words “balloon seller,” so tired and disgusted was I with my non-idea for a non-costume, so frustrated by my inability to justify, to myself or anyone else, why I was wearing this stupid coat. I had nothing to say, and bowed out of my social responsibilities, as I often do, with the grace of a log.
She was wearing a red baseball hat, backwards or cocked to the side, and I think her shirt was pulled and tied in a knot at the back. All her friends were dressed the same. The colors were red, maybe black, and white. Someone asked what they were. She said she was nookie. Like that song. Fred Durst’s band, what was their name? I did it all for the nookie. Limp Bizkit.
Limp Bizkit was a popular musical act, circa the earliest of the years I spent being awkward and dressing in oversized black coats. They were loud, dumb, and boorish, and their most popular song featured the refrain, “I did it all for the nookie, yeah! The nookie, yeah! So you can take that cookie, and stick it up your, yeah! Stick it up your, yeah! Stick it up your, yeah! And stick it up your, yeah!”
At the time it was not clear to me exactly what nookie was, and so nagging was my uncertainty that I much later looked it up just to pin it down, but seeing these girls I got the general idea. I now knew with certainty that was not a nonsense word, like those that featured in so many pop hooks of that era, but instead a word that referred to something a little dirty, something a little cheap, something sexual but not sexy, something childish and duchey.
My blond acquaintance was dressed like we had seen Fred Durst, the lead singer, dress in the video for this song. It is an ugly and smug wardrobe, the highlight of which is the aforementioned bright baseball cap, which says simply, I may be stupid, but I’m also mean, so stay the fuck out of my way. On her the outfit was tighter, and seemed sadder, less bullying and more tragic. She was volunteering to be the target of his cat calls, the willing subject of his leering and his arrogant appetite. It skived me out. I had that sense that history would not look kindly on her costume. Limp Bizkit never seemed like a keeper to me, and in my experience grown women did not subject themselves to this sort of thing, so presumably there was a moment when one left that kind of desperation and degradation behind. I hoped there was. Despite my balloons and wanting to disappear, I left feeling embarrassed for her.
I’ve accused myself of being judgemental and prude more times than you’ll ever manage, so don’t think I’m not aware of how I sound. She was young, Pop lust rarely hurts anyone, and playacting the part of a sexually desirable and available woman is often harmless, even charming and pleasantly embarrassing in hindsight. I had my own reasons for reacting the way I did. She was frighteningly confident, glamorous, and inaccessible, and things were much simpler if I could pity her. Her overeager embrace of sex didn’t have to highlight my own nervousness and inability to feel desirable if I could, instead, laugh it off. And of course, my failure of a costume wasn’t so bad once you considered I might have gone as nookie itself.
I hope she’s doing well. There were other things over the years that fed my pity, like her tendency to slavishly follow around a certain bossy alpha girl, and hints of a relationship with a boy who was significantly older and therefore potentially dangerous. Her fragility may have been all in my mind. It’s still a powerful memory. I wanted then to protect her, from the world, from herself. I wanted to be the beautiful and confident one, wanted to take her away, release her from the politics and paranoia of middle school. I would offer instead the serenity and solidity of my maturity, and she would be so grateful, so relieved to take off the nookie costume and leave her stupid friends behind forever. Most importantly, she would see me as I really was, not mumbling and sincerely hoping to vanish, but smiling gregariously, putting everyone at ease, charming, sparkling, shining.
—
I don’t know why but no other costumes, no other Halloweens, come readily to mind. I’ll think about it and try to figure out what else I put together. Somehow the adrenaline coursing through my system in my embarrassment has made that one night my brain’s go to story about the holiday and left no room for others. Some years I may have not attempted anything, figuring (correctly) that dismissing questions about my lack of a costume would be easier than finding something good or suffering something bad. It wasn’t like I got good at it after a while. The costuming was never really my thing.
I know people who are not me have memories of elaborate childhood costumes, and parents working overtime, or that time you had the best idea ever, and whether or not it worked, it was a glorious making the attempt. If you want to share a best or worst costume, explain why you’d rather fly than turn invisible, or talk about being dumped or fired or the songs your father taught you, write me at thisjoyfulnoise@gmail.com. I’d love to hear your stories.