I recently realized I’d put these two songs next to each other on a mix I’d made, and they happen to be among my favorite songs ever. I also really enjoy how sublime and ridiculous it is to hear them next to each other. I suppose if I were forced to supply an organizing theme to this post, I could say that it includes the most offensive and the least offensive song you could sing to a loved one that I own.
First up, “Closer” by Nine Inch Nails.
The secret of “Closer” is that it’s really two very different songs. Those famous lyrics that make the song so readily identifiable, so disgusting, and so easy to write off as a novelty (or heresy), don’t have anything to do with what makes this track one for the ages. The first half of “Closer” is an evil pop song, complete with disco hi hat and wild funk bassline, which proceeds orderly from verse to chorus to verse to chorus. Yes, the lyrics are absurdly angsty teenage poetry, and yes, he sings “I want to fuck you like an animal” a couple times like the attention hungry rock star he is. It’s a curiosity, a well produced but over the top hymn to some intentionally melodramatic and laughably self-serious sexuality.
After the third minute, “Closer” is a whole different animal. Feel free to skip forward to hear what I’m talking about. Virtually instrumental from here on out, it builds with purring, fuzzy guitars and then sharp fantastic synth blurps and beats, a mean, tight, low rhythm section, some kind of electronic funk, industrial funk, metal funk, ahh there are no words for how tight this is. Notice the chorus of the first half never even threatens to rear its head past the three minute mark. Soon we get these insistent piano chords, Depeche Mode in a bad mood, and if you listen Reznor’s production here is really astounding, especially the guitars that sound like motorcycles. There’s still that funk smack on the bass, it’s never gone away, and then at 4:47 the track grows even further with higher synth lines, and then at 5:07 some crazy smacking drums come in alongside humming, sneering, distorted gutars, and then 5:30 or so the drums just go apeshit, step right up to the edge of godliness, for a brief few seconds standing on top of a monument of sound as sexy and insane and powerful as anything I’ve ever heard. A tiny little descending melody is precariously placed on top of all these layers, and that theme (which isn’t heard once in the first half – nothing so tender or vulnerable made its way into that section) is what I always think of as the “Closer” melody. Notice also how Reznor is so confident in this monstrous creation of his that he doesn’t repeat it, not once, he gives it no time to sink in, to convince you – we get literally twenty seconds of it.
The second half is slightly over three minutes, outweighing the dry pathology of the first half, and is (I humbly proclaim) a crowning achievement of popular music. The desperate lust that the first half makes laughable is expressed elegantly, powerfully, and nearly transcendently by the second half. It’s a shame they’re buried behind three minutes of calculatedly offensive, really bad poetry.
If you didn’t quite get what was so fantastic about that second half, turn up the volume, close your eyes, and try again.
Next up, “Every Morning” by Keb Mo.
Our friends at Pitchfork would probably describe “Every Morning” by Keb Mo as MOR. I readily admit I had to look this snarky acronym up; turns out it stands for “Middle Of the Road,” which they consider the ultimate end all and be all of little nasty things to say about an album they don’t like. Well, hell. A great song’s just a great song. This one’s a simple, bluesly pop number, and it’s a love song, only not the kind of love song Pitchfork writers like; it doesn’t apologize for or cover up for the fact that it’s a love song, or make ironic reference to the fact that it’s a love song, and the fact that everyone writes love songs, and that they’re cheesy and silly but we have to keep writing them because that’s just what love makes us want to do. It’s not embarassed about being simple, or lovely; it revels in it. This is why we invented music, it says, remember? This is what music can do. Yeah, we can provide a soundtrack to pain and worry and hearbreak and anger, to politics and drugs and sex, we can glorify anything you think is worth glorifying (and a few things you don’t) and get down on tape a million things that make you uncomfortable, that push that poor, endlessly abused envelope. But dear god in heaven look what music can do with love. Look what it can do with tenderness, with happiness, with uncomplicated caring between two people. I can’t help but think we should be able to produce pop songs as uncomplicated and as appealing as those pleasant, formulaic, clever love songs in the 30s and 40s, the ones pumped out by Gershwin and Berlin, even if that exact format is rightfully over. Humanity, and our art, can’t really be shackled by irony, its much too powerful for that. We can do this, make beautiful unembarassed music. We can. Maybe the best of the cheesy Latino pop ballads achieve something similar. I don’t know..
The great thing about “Every Morning” is that it sounds like love. It’s not just the hallmark lyrics (“when I’m with you it feels like heaven, you’re an angel holding me, you’re sweet sweet loving it sets me free”) that let you know, but the lovely guitar, and the lovely voice. There is a hint of sorrow to his love, in the lyrics (“in my wildest imagination I could never imagine you loving me as much as I do you”), in the aching blue notes the guitar introduces, and in the gentle, sighing melody. But that’s love for you. And I’m damn proud of him for capturing it so well.
“It may be winter it may be fall/I might have plenty or nothin at all/but baby I’ll be there whenever you call.”
The blues has always worn simplicity well; although in the hands of an amateur it can sound cheesy and trite, successful blues singers make it crystal clear that just a few words can say volumes, and they make this come true through the sheer power of their confidence in what they’re singing. Sometimes things can be expressed better in a few words than in a million (cough this post cough). There is a lot of beauty that has been found by experimenting with the blues, by electrifying it and embellishing it and warping and distorting it, and thousands of musicians have followed this course. But there’s something about the acoustic blues that nothing can touch. It’s the foundation, the heart, of all modern popular music, but it achieves something direct and true and beautiful that all its descendants only very rarely create. The blues is also just fantastic as popular music, as something everyone recognizes, anyone can pick up. Its just so obvious, so simple, so easy to do, and so hard to do well. Keb Mo reminds us what it sounds like when done well.
“Every morning and every evening/every day I think of you/the way you love me through and through.”
And now, for your listening pleasure, lust, love, and the fantastic range of popular music on display:
Closer
Every Morning
These juxtapositions are one of my favorite ways of enjoying music, and finding ways to see old music in new light. It’s not my phrase, but I love to think of these posts as “tiny little mixtapes.” Expect more of them.